Vertical and Horizontal Reservations in India

By Shivank Goel|Updated : September 16th, 2022

Vertical and Horizontal Reservations are the two types of reservations under the reservation policy in India. India is a vast country. It is rich in its cultural heritage and natural resources. But,  the nation has failed to make optimum use of its resources. It has been home to several civilizations which have prospered and perished. The glory of the past has been buried beneath mounds of ruins. Perhaps they have left indelible marks on the life and culture of India. Unfortunately, some of these legacies have become a hindrance to our progress.

Two significant remnants of a problematic mindset are castes and classes, posing substantial obstacles in the path towards national integration and unity. After independence, in the first step towards social justice, GOI introduced reservations like vertical and horizontal reservations for SC/ST/OBCs in education and public employment through constitutional amendments in the 1950s. Many thinkers have criticized these reservations, and political leaders on various grounds, as the Vertical and Horizontal Reservations, are based on caste (birth) rather than merit.

Table of Content

What are Vertical and Horizontal Reservations?

Reservation in India refers to affirmative action practised by the government of India to improve the backwardness of certain castes, communities, and religious minorities. Currently, two types of reservations exist in India, i.e., horizontal and vertical reservations. The scheduled castes (SCs), scheduled tribes (STs), and other backward classes (OBCs) are the primary beneficiaries of the reservation policies under Indian law.

Download Vertical and Horizontal Reservations Notes PDF

Let us look at the two types of reservations in India under the reservation policy, i.e., Vertical and Horizontal Reservations, in detail -

What is Horizontal Reservation?

Horizontal reservation is a form of affirmative action that seeks to promote the inclusion of socially and economically backward groups by guaranteeing them a fixed proportion of positions in employment, education, and representation at the political level.

Since these reservations are proportional to the population of a particular section, they do not affect the relative position of different areas vis-a-vis each other. For example, if there is a 25% reservation for lower castes (SC/ST/OBC) in central government jobs, it will be 25% for every post the government creates. The number of reserved seats will depend on the number of posts made.

Such groups include

  • Children of veterans who are serving in the armed forces retired or are killed in action.
  • Disabled persons.
  • Widows and unmarried women.
  • People from rural areas.

What is Vertical Reservation?

Vertical reservation is a form of reservation that seeks to uplift socially or economically underprivileged groups. Under this type of reservation, the state creates separate classes or categories within an educational institution or service and reserves seats in those categories for the section which is being uplifted. In this type of reservation, there is no guarantee that members belonging to a particular group will get one specific seat every time an opportunity arises.

The Constitution of India provides reservations in education and employment to citizens' socially and educationally backward classes (SEBCs). However, right from the beginning, this provision has been facing constitutional challenges to the extent of being ultra vires in Articles 15 and 16 of the Constitution.

Difference between Vertical and Horizontal Reservation

The difference between vertical and horizontal reservations in India is explained in the table below-

Vertical Reservation

Horizontal Reservation

Vertical Reservation is the reservation for the people belonging to the backward classes.

Horizontal reservation is the reservation for the disadvantaged group in society.

It promotes the inclusion of socially and economically backward groups, i.e., lower castes (SC/ST/OBC)

It is a reservation for Children of veterans who are serving in the armed forces, retired or killed in action, disabled persons, widows and unmarried women, and people from rural areas.

The limit for reservations was extended to 40% after the introduction of EWS Reservation

The reservation number depends upon the number of seats available.

Article 16(4 deals with the Vertical Reservation

Article 15(3) deals with Horizontal Reservation.

Significance of Vertical and Horizontal Reservations

The policy of reservation that is in place in India is an example of positive discrimination. It gives preferential treatment to certain groups in society to support and aid the groups that have been lagging in many aspects due to different reasons. Having such a policy in place would help these groups access higher education and government jobs, which were previously out of their prospects

The debate arises in society and the political field when the question of who deserves such vertical and horizontal reservations comes up.

How does Vertical and Horizontal Reservation work?

Vertical and Horizontal Reservation is the need of the hour, which can ensure overall reservation for the Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and Other Backward Classes. This will help in eliminating the inequality between the upper castes and lower castes in our country. But one of the major questions can a person be eligible for two categories at the same instance of time?

The explanation to this question can be understood from the Saurav Yadav vs The State of Uttar Pradesh Case.

Saurav Yadav vs The State of Uttar Pradesh Case

In 2020, Saurav Yadav raised a case against the state of Uttar Pradesh in the Supreme court. In this case, Rita Rani had secured 233.1908 while Sonam Tomar scored 276.59 marks. Rita applied under the SC- female category and Sonam applied for the OBC-female one. Another girl who scored 274.82 marks under the general category was selected but these two were not considered as qualifying.

To this, the two judged penal of the Supreme Court ruled against the government of Uttar Pradesh. According to the court, if a candidate belonging to two reserved categories (i.e., at an intersection of the vertical-horizontal reserved category) will be considered as qualifying under the vertical as well as horizontal category.

Other Important UPSC Notes
Difference Between Bureaucracy and DemocracyThe Red Corridor States 2022
Difference Between Civil Law and Criminal Law Difference Between Classical and Folk Dance
Difference Between Collector and District MagistrateDifference Between Colonialism and Imperialism
Redressal of Grievances in IndiaDifference Between Commissioner and DGP
Essential Commodities Act 1955SATAT Initiative

Comments

write a comment

FAQs on Vertical and Horizontal Reservations

  • Vertical and Horizontal Reservations help groups acquire and retain advantages that others lack. It is one of the prime types of positive discrimination among different groups in society. It works for the upliftment of the economically and socially backward units of society.

  • The reason for having Horizontal and Vertical Reservations is that it can lead to increased access to resources and opportunities for disadvantaged groups, which they may not otherwise be able to get.

  • EWS or Economically Weaker Section reservation is a type of vertical reservation. Since 1 February 2019, the candidates belonging to the EWS category have enjoyed a 10% reservation in government sector jobs and education under the vertical category reservation.

  • Vertical reservation is for the people belonging to the so-called backward classes. Horizontal reservation is for other disadvantaged groups like women, children, transgender people, people with disabilities, etc.

  • The disadvantage of providing Vertical and Horizontal Reservations to a certain group of individuals is that all are not provided equal opportunities to reach a certain status. The low-scoring candidates belonging to the reserved category enjoy an advantage over the high-scoring general category candidates.

  • Horizontal reservation is given to a class or group of people within the same category or level. For example, SC/ST/OBC are grouped under one class and given horizontal reservation. For eg. Physically Handicapped persons reservation.

  • Vertical reservation is the reservation of seats in institutions for those from a particular caste, class, and gender. This type of reservation is provided to those historically discriminated against. These include people from lower castes, women, physically-challenged people, etc.

Featured Articles

Follow us for latest updates